Two Short Planks
The puzzle
A square island sits in the middle of a square moat, the moat being 4 m wide all round, with the island's edges parallel to the outer edges. You have two planks, each 3.9 m long.
Neither plank reaches across the 4 m of water. How do you get to the island?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
You will not find a narrower line: across a corner the gap is 4 x sqrt(2) = 5.66 m, which is worse. So stop looking for a single span.
Hint 2
A plank laid across the corner with both ends on the outer bank is a pier. What can you then reach from the middle of it?
Show the answer Hide the answer
Lay one plank across the corner with both ends on the outer bank, then rest the second plank from the middle of the first to the island's corner. The second span is 3.71 m - just inside 3.9 m.
How to get there
Put the outer corner at the origin with the banks along the axes. The island's nearest corner is then at (4, 4). Lay the first plank across the corner, ends on the two banks, pushed out as far as it will go: a 3.9 m plank placed symmetrically has its feet 3.9/sqrt(2) = 2.76 m from the corner along each bank, and its midpoint at (1.38, 1.38).
Measure from that midpoint to the island corner: both coordinates differ by 2.62 m, so the distance is 2.62 x sqrt(2) = 3.71 m. The second plank is 3.9 m, so it reaches, with about 19 cm to spare for bearing. Rest one end on the middle of the first plank and the other on the island, and walk across.
The margin is genuinely thin, and the general condition shows why: the second span is sqrt(2)*w - L/2, so a plank of length L crosses a moat of width w only when L is at least 2*sqrt(2)*w/3. For w = 4 that is 3.77 m. Planks of 3.5 m would not do it, however cleverly they were laid - the trick has a limit, and it is worth knowing where.
The technique worth keeping
When no single move spans a gap, build a pier: a structure that supports itself part of the way and shortens what remains. Then check the arithmetic, because a construction that works in a diagram may not work in metres.