The Three-Way Duel

  • Hard
  • Game strategy puzzles
  • Tests: Seeing that a successful shot can be a mistake

The puzzle

Three people duel in turn: Abel hits 1 shot in 3, Bruno 2 in 3, and Carr never misses. They fire in order of increasing skill - Abel, then Bruno, then Carr - repeating, skipping anyone already eliminated, and each shoots to serve their own survival.

Abel shoots first. What should he aim at?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

If Abel hits Bruno, who shoots next, and at whom?

Hint 2

Consider deliberately missing. What does that leave Bruno and Carr to do about each other?

Show the answer Hide the answer

Abel should fire into the air. Shooting at either opponent leaves him facing the survivor first; missing on purpose makes Bruno and Carr deal with each other while Abel waits.

How to get there

Suppose Abel shoots at Carr and hits. Then it is Bruno's turn against Abel, and Bruno hits two times in three - Abel is very likely dead before he fires again. Suppose instead Abel shoots at Bruno and hits: now Carr, who never misses, is next, and Abel is certainly dead.

So any successful shot is a disaster: it promotes Abel to being the next target of a better shot. Deliberately missing leaves all three standing, and it is Bruno's turn. Bruno must shoot at Carr - leaving Carr alive guarantees Bruno's death - and he hits two times in three.

Either Bruno kills Carr, and Abel then faces Bruno with the first shot; or Bruno misses, Carr kills Bruno as the greater threat, and Abel faces Carr with the first shot. Both branches are better for Abel than anything his own bullet could achieve, because in each he shoots first at a single opponent rather than second. Being the weakest player is a shield as long as stronger players have each other to worry about.

The technique worth keeping

Evaluate a move by the position it creates, not by whether it succeeds. In multi-player games, eliminating a rival often transfers their enemies to you - which is why passing can dominate acting.