Archimedes' Tombstone
The puzzle
A sphere sits snugly inside a cylinder - the cylinder's diameter and height both equal the sphere's diameter.
What fraction of the cylinder does the sphere occupy? Archimedes asked for the answer to be carved on his tombstone.
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
Give the sphere radius r. Then the cylinder has radius r and height 2r.
Hint 2
Sphere: 4/3 pi r³. Cylinder: pi r² times height.
Show the answer Hide the answer
Exactly two thirds — and the sphere's surface area is two thirds of the cylinder's too.
How to get there
With radius r the sphere has volume 4/3 pi r³. The cylinder has radius r and height 2r, so its volume is pi r² × 2r = 2 pi r³.
The ratio is (4/3 pi r³)/(2 pi r³) = 2/3. Everything cancels: the answer does not depend on the size, only on the snug fit.
The same 2/3 holds for the surfaces. The sphere's area is 4 pi r² and the cylinder's total area is 2 pi r² (ends) + 4 pi r² (side) = 6 pi r². Archimedes considered this his finest result and asked for the figure to be put on his grave; Cicero found the tombstone a century and a half later by looking for it.
The technique worth keeping
For a ratio, write both quantities symbolically and divide before substituting. Anything that cancels was never part of the answer, and a ratio that comes out as a bare number means the shape, not the size, decided it.