A Coin Rolled Around a Coin

  • Medium
  • Geometry and grid puzzles
  • Tests: Separating rotation about a centre from rotation in place

The puzzle

Two identical coins lie flat on a table. One is fixed. You roll the other around it without slipping, until it returns to its starting position.

How many full revolutions has the rolling coin made?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Mark a point on the rim of the rolling coin and watch it, not the coin.

Hint 2

The centre of the rolling coin travels a circle of radius 2r, not r.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Two. Not one, which is what the touching rims suggest.

How to get there

The two coins have equal radius r. The rolling coin's centre stays 2r from the fixed coin's centre, so that centre travels a circle of circumference 2*pi*(2r) = 4*pi*r.

Rolling without slipping means the rolling coin turns through one revolution for every 2*pi*r of travel by its centre. So 4*pi*r of travel is exactly two revolutions.

The "one revolution" answer comes from thinking about the contact length: the fixed rim is 2*pi*r long, so only 2*pi*r of rim is rolled over. True - but the coin also rotates once simply by going round the loop, the way the Moon keeps one face towards us while still turning once per orbit. Contact rotation plus orbital rotation gives two.

The technique worth keeping

Rotation is measured against a fixed frame, not against the thing you are rolling on. Track the path of the centre and divide by the circumference - that counts both contributions and cannot lose one.