Pennies on a Round Table
The puzzle
Two players take turns placing identical coins flat on a round table. Coins may not overlap or hang over the edge. The player who cannot place a coin loses.
Who wins with perfect play, and how?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
The table has a centre and is symmetric about it.
Hint 2
If your opponent can place a coin somewhere, what can you say about the point diametrically opposite?
Show the answer Hide the answer
The first player wins: place the first coin exactly at the centre, then mirror every opponent move through the centre.
How to get there
Put the first coin dead centre. The remaining free area is now symmetric about that point.
Whenever the opponent places a coin, the position rotated 180 degrees about the centre must also be free - the layout was symmetric before their move, and their coin cannot overlap its own mirror image because the centre is already occupied.
So you always have a reply, and symmetry is restored after each of your turns. The opponent runs out of room first.
The technique worth keeping
Break the symmetry once in your favour, then restore it every turn. The centre coin is what stops a move and its mirror from colliding, which is the detail that makes this argument airtight rather than nearly right.