The Balance With Unequal Arms

  • Medium
  • Measuring and weighing
  • Tests: Cancelling a systematic error

The puzzle

A market balance has arms of slightly different lengths, so it reads wrong. Put a sack in the left pan and it balances against 9 kg of standard weights; put the same sack in the right pan and it balances against 16 kg.

What does the sack actually weigh? The honest answer is not 12.5.

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

A balance balances when weight times arm length matches on both sides.

Hint 2

Write both weighings as equations and multiply them together rather than adding.

Show the answer Hide the answer

12 kg - the geometric mean of 9 and 16, not the average of them.

How to get there

Let the arms be a and b and the true weight W. Sack on the left: W*a = 9*b. Sack on the right: 16*a = W*b.

Rearrange each to isolate the arm ratio. The first gives b/a = W/9; the second gives b/a = 16/W. The balance has not changed between weighings, so those two expressions are equal: W/9 = 16/W, hence W^2 = 144 and W = 12 kg.

The unknown arm ratio cancelled, which is the point of weighing in both pans. The arithmetic mean (9 + 16)/2 = 12.5 is wrong because the error is multiplicative, not additive: one weighing is inflated by b/a and the other deflated by the same factor, so the two readings bracket the truth geometrically.

The technique worth keeping

A proportional bias cancels under multiplication, not subtraction. Measure the same quantity twice with the bias reversed and take the geometric mean - the standard trick for weighing on a crooked balance.