Two Napkin Rings

  • Hard
  • Geometry and grid puzzles
  • Tests: Finding the variable that does not matter

The puzzle

Take a sphere and drill a cylindrical hole straight through its centre, so that what remains is a band - a napkin ring. Do it again with a much larger sphere and a much wider drill, so that this second ring has exactly the same height as the first.

Which ring contains more material: the one from the small sphere or the one from the large sphere?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

Call the ring's height h and write its volume in terms of h and the sphere's radius. Watch what happens to the radius.

Hint 2

The answer is the volume of a sphere whose diameter is h.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Neither. Two napkin rings of the same height have the same volume, whatever the spheres they came from. For h = 6 cm that volume is pi*h^3/6, about 113 cm^3.

How to get there

Let the sphere have radius R and let the ring have height h, so the hole has radius a with a^2 = R^2 - (h/2)^2. The ring is the sphere's volume minus the cylinder minus the two spherical caps.

Carrying that subtraction through, every term in R cancels and what is left is pi*h^3/6 - precisely the volume of a sphere of diameter h. The sphere you started from has vanished from the answer.

So a 6 cm ring drilled from a grapefruit and a 6 cm ring drilled from the Earth hold the same amount of material: pi*6^3/6 = 36*pi, about 113 cm^3. The bigger sphere gives a wider, thinner band; the smaller sphere a narrower, fatter one, and the trade is exact.

The technique worth keeping

When a problem offers two free parameters and fixes one combination of them, write the answer symbolically before substituting. Cancellation is the proof that the remaining parameter was never relevant.