The Missing Pound

  • Medium
  • Number puzzles
  • Tests: Spotting a sum that adds the wrong things together

The puzzle

Three guests take a room advertised at £30 and pay £10 each. The manager realises the room is only £25 and sends a porter up with £5. The porter pockets £2 and hands each guest £1.

Each guest has now paid £9, so 3 x £9 = £27. Add the porter's £2 and you get £29. Where is the missing pound?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

There is no missing pound. There is a wrong sum.

Hint 2

The £27 the guests paid already includes the porter's £2. Adding it again double-counts.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Nothing is missing. The £27 paid out splits as £25 to the hotel plus £2 to the porter, and the guests hold £3. The puzzle adds the porter's £2 to a total that already contains it.

How to get there

Follow the money. £30 went in. £3 came back to the guests, so £27 stayed in the hotel. Of that £27, the hotel has £25 and the porter has £2. 25 + 2 = 27, and 27 + 3 = 30. Every pound is accounted for.

The puzzle's sum, 27 + 2 = 29, adds a payment to a part of itself. The £27 is money the guests handed over; the £2 is a slice of that same £27. Adding them is like adding your salary to your rent and expecting a meaningful number.

The correct pairing is either 27 + 3 = 30 (what was paid, plus what was refunded) or 25 + 2 + 3 = 30 (hotel, porter, guests). The £29 is close enough to £30 to feel like an error of one pound, which is the whole trick - a figure of £17 would have fooled nobody.

The technique worth keeping

When a total is one short, check that the things being added are disjoint. Set out a flow of funds - in, out, held by whom - and the double count becomes visible immediately.