The Man in the Tunnel
The puzzle
A man is one third of the way into a railway tunnel when he hears a train coming towards the near end. If he runs back he reaches that end at the instant the train does. If instead he runs forward he reaches the far end at the instant the train does.
How many times faster than the man is the train?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
Call the tunnel length L and the train's distance from the near entrance d. Write both races as equal-time equations.
Hint 2
Dividing one equation by the other eliminates the speeds and leaves you with d.
Show the answer Hide the answer
Three times. The train is exactly one tunnel-length from the entrance when he starts.
How to get there
Running back, the man covers L/3 while the train covers d, so (L/3)/v = d/u. Running forward, he covers 2L/3 while the train covers d + L, so (2L/3)/v = (d + L)/u.
Divide the first by the second: (L/3)/(2L/3) = d/(d + L), so 1/2 = d/(d + L), giving d + L = 2d and therefore d = L.
Substituting back: (L/3)/v = L/u, so u/v = 3. The train runs at three times the man's speed and is one full tunnel-length away when he starts. Notice that neither the tunnel's length nor either actual speed was ever needed - two tied races give exactly enough to fix the ratio.
The technique worth keeping
Two conditions that both end in a dead heat give two equations. Dividing them cancels the unknown speeds and leaves a single relation between the distances, which is usually the whole answer.