Four Cards and a Rule

  • Medium
  • Logical puzzles
  • Tests: Testing a rule by trying to break it

The puzzle

Four cards lie on a table. Each has a letter on one side and a number on the other. You can see: A, K, 4, 7.

Someone claims: "If a card has a vowel on one side, then it has an even number on the other." Which cards must you turn over to test whether the claim is false?

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

You are looking for a card that could break the rule, not one that could confirm it.

Hint 2

The rule says nothing about consonants, and nothing about what must be on the back of an even number.

Show the answer Hide the answer

Two cards: A and 7. Turning over 4 is the popular wrong answer.

How to get there

A rule of the form "if vowel then even" is broken by exactly one thing: a vowel with an odd number on the back. So turn over any card that could be that.

A is a vowel - if its other side is odd, the rule is false, so it must be turned. 7 is odd - if its other side is a vowel, the rule is false, so it must be turned too.

K is a consonant and the rule makes no claim about consonants, so whatever is on its back is irrelevant. 4 is even - a vowel behind it agrees with the rule and a consonant behind it is simply not covered, so it cannot break the rule either way. Most people pick A and 4, choosing the card that could confirm the rule rather than the one that could refute it.

The technique worth keeping

To test "if P then Q", look for P-and-not-Q. That means checking the cases where P holds and the cases where Q fails - never the cases where Q holds, however confirmatory they feel.