Who Keeps the Fish?
The puzzle
Five houses stand in a row, numbered 1 to 5 from the left. Each is lived in by a person of a different nationality - Norwegian, Dane, Briton, German, Swede - who drinks a different drink - tea, coffee, milk, beer, water - and keeps a different pet - cat, horse, bird, dog, fish.
The clues: (1) the Briton lives in the middle house; (2) the Norwegian lives in the first house; (3) the Dane drinks tea; (4) the milk drinker lives next door to the Norwegian; (5) the Swede keeps a dog; (6) the coffee drinker lives in the last house; (7) the bird keeper lives immediately to the left of the beer drinker; (8) the cat owner lives next door to the Dane; (9) the horse keeper drinks water. Who keeps the fish?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
Clues 1, 2, 4 and 6 pin down positions directly. Start there and draw the grid.
Hint 2
Once the Norwegian's drink is known, clue 9 places the horse, and clue 7 is the one that fixes the middle of the row.
Show the answer Hide the answer
The Dane, in house 4. The full row is Norwegian-water-horse, German-milk-bird, Briton-beer-cat, Dane-tea-fish, Swede-coffee-dog.
How to get there
Clue 2 puts the Norwegian in house 1 and clue 1 puts the Briton in house 3. Clue 4 says milk is next to the Norwegian, so milk is in house 2. Clue 6 puts coffee in house 5. Tea, beer and water are left for houses 1, 3 and 4.
Clue 3 says the Dane drinks tea, and the Dane is not in house 1 or 3, so the Dane is in house 4 with tea. That leaves beer and water for houses 1 and 3. Clue 7 needs the bird immediately left of the beer, and clue 9 ties the horse to the water. If beer were in house 1 there would be no house to its left, so beer is in house 3 and water in house 1.
Then clue 9 gives the Norwegian in house 1 the horse, and clue 7 puts the bird in house 2. Clue 8 puts the cat next to the Dane - house 3 or 5 - and clue 5 gives the Swede the dog. The Swede must be in house 2 or 5, and house 2 has the bird, so the Swede is in house 5 with the dog; the German takes house 2. The cat is therefore in house 3 and the fish in house 4 - the Dane's.
The technique worth keeping
Work the positional clues first, because they remove whole rows of the grid at once. Then look for the clue that cannot be satisfied in more than one way - here "immediately to the left of" fails at the end of the row, and that single impossibility unlocks the rest.