The Brakeman, the Fireman and the Engineer
The puzzle
Three railwaymen are named Smith, Jones and Robinson; so are three passengers, distinguished as Mr Smith, Mr Jones and Mr Robinson. We know: Mr Robinson lives in Leeds; the brakeman lives halfway between Leeds and Sheffield; Mr Jones earns exactly £2,000 a year; the brakeman's nearest neighbour, one of the passengers, earns exactly three times what the brakeman earns; Smith beats the fireman at billiards; and the passenger whose name matches the brakeman's lives in Sheffield.
What is the engineer's name?
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
The brakeman's neighbour earns three times the brakeman's salary, and £2,000 does not divide by three.
Hint 2
Work out who the brakeman is first. Everything else follows from the billiards clue.
Show the answer Hide the answer
Smith is the engineer.
How to get there
The neighbour earns three times the brakeman's salary, so the neighbour's salary is divisible by three. Mr Jones earns £2,000, which is not, so the neighbour is not Mr Jones. Mr Robinson lives in Leeds and the brakeman lives halfway between the cities, so Mr Robinson is not the neighbour either. The neighbour is Mr Smith.
The passenger sharing the brakeman's name lives in Sheffield. Mr Smith lives next to the brakeman, halfway between the cities, so the brakeman is not Smith. Mr Robinson lives in Leeds, not Sheffield, so the brakeman is not Robinson. The brakeman is Jones.
Smith beats the fireman at billiards, so Smith is not the fireman, and he is not the brakeman either. Smith is the engineer - and Robinson is left as the fireman. The six names exist purely so that two clues can be about passengers while the question is about railwaymen.
The technique worth keeping
Negative clues - "earns an amount not divisible by three", "lives somewhere else" - eliminate as effectively as positive ones. Work the one that rules out the most first, and keep passengers and railwaymen in separate columns so a clue about one is never read as a clue about the other.