One Metre of Extra Rope

  • Medium
  • Geometry and grid puzzles
  • Tests: Trusting algebra over scale

The puzzle

A rope is pulled taut around the equator, touching the ground the whole way. You cut it, splice in one extra metre, and arrange the slack so the rope floats at the same height above the ground all the way round.

How high off the ground is it? Most people answer "far too little to see". Work it out before you commit to that.

Stuck?

One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.

Hint 1

You are not asked for the height. You are asked for the change in radius.

Hint 2

Circumference is 2*pi*r, so a change in circumference of 1 means a change in r of 1/(2*pi) - and the Earth's own radius never enters the sum.

Show the answer Hide the answer

About 16 cm - roughly 0.159 m. Enough to step over, and the same answer for a rope around a tennis ball.

How to get there

Let the Earth's radius be R, so the rope was 2*pi*R long. The new rope is 2*pi*R + 1, and if it sits at radius R + h then its length is 2*pi*(R + h) = 2*pi*R + 2*pi*h.

Setting those equal gives 2*pi*h = 1, so h = 1/(2*pi) = 0.159 m. R cancelled out of the sum entirely - it was never going to matter.

That is the whole surprise. The height depends only on the metre you added, so a rope round the equator and a rope round an orange both rise by 16 cm when you lengthen them by a metre. Intuition fails because it quietly assumes the answer should be a proportion of something, and here nothing is proportional.

The technique worth keeping

When a quantity feels like it must depend on scale, write both cases algebraically and subtract. Whatever cancels was never part of the answer, and seeing it cancel is more convincing than any amount of estimating.