Four Balls and a Known-Good One
The puzzle
Four balls, one of which is either heavier or lighter than the rest. You also have one ball known to be genuine.
Find the odd ball and its direction in two weighings.
Stuck?
One at a time, smallest first. Open only as many as you need — the whole point of the puzzle is the part you work out yourself.
Hint 1
There are 8 cases and two weighings give 9 outcomes, so it is just possible.
Hint 2
The genuine ball lets you weigh two suspects against one suspect plus it.
Show the answer Hide the answer
Weigh balls 1 and 2 against ball 3 and the genuine one. Every outcome leaves at most three cases, which the second weighing separates.
How to get there
Count first: 4 balls × 2 directions = 8 cases, and two weighings give 3² = 9 outcomes. It fits, with one outcome to spare.
Weigh {1,2} against {3,G}. If they balance, 1, 2 and 3 are genuine and ball 4 is the odd one - weigh 4 against G to learn the direction. If the left side falls, then 1 or 2 is heavy, or 3 is light: three cases, settled by weighing 1 against 2.
If the left side rises, the mirror image: 1 or 2 is light, or 3 is heavy, and 1 against 2 settles it again. The genuine ball is what makes the first weighing possible at all - without it you cannot put three suspects on the scales with equal counts in each pan.
The technique worth keeping
A known-good item lets you load the pans with unequal numbers of suspects, which is often the only way to split the cases three ways. Check the outcome count first, then design the split to make each branch fit.