Seating Arrangement

  • Logical Reasoning
  • 10 worked examples
  • 5 rules to know

What it is

These look long and are not hard. A set of clues describes who sits where, and the work is bookkeeping: draw the row or the circle, write in what is certain, and let the remaining clues eliminate the rest.

The one thing that separates people who finish from people who do not is starting with the clue that fixes a position absolutely, rather than with the first clue on the list. "B sits at the end" is worth five clues of the form "C sits next to D".

What you need to know

  1. Draw it. A row with numbered places, or a circle with marked seats. Every one of these questions is faster on paper than in your head.
  2. Start with absolute positions - ends, middles, named seats - then clues joining two people, then negative clues last.
  3. In a circle, "left" and "right" depend on whether people face the centre. Facing inwards, a person's left is clockwise from your point of view as you look at the page.
  4. A clue like "A is third to the left of B" fixes a distance, not a position - it gives you a shape you can slide along until something else pins it.
  5. When two arrangements both survive every clue, the question is under-specified and the answer is whatever both have in common.

Worked examples

Try each one before opening the answer. A solution you have read is not a solution you can produce under time pressure, which is the only kind that counts.

Q1 Five friends A, B, C, D, E sit in a row. C is at one end. B is next to C. A is in the middle. Where can D and E sit?

Show the answer Hide the answer

D and E take the two remaining places — positions 4 and 5 if C is at position 1 — in either order.

Say C is at 1. B next to C puts B at 2. A in the middle of five is position 3. That leaves 4 and 5 for D and E, and nothing distinguishes them, so both orders are valid. Recognising that a question is under-specified is as useful as solving one that is not.

Q2 Six people sit at a circular table whose seats are numbered 1 to 6 clockwise. A is at seat 1 and D sits directly opposite A. B is at seat 2. Which seat is directly opposite B?

Show the answer Hide the answer

Seat 5.

With six seats, "opposite" is three places round: seat 1 faces seat 4, which is where D sits, and that confirms the rule on the pair you were given. Applying it to B at seat 2 gives 2 + 3 = 5. Numbering the seats before reading the clues is what keeps a circular question from turning on which way people face.

Q3 Seven people sit in a row. P is fourth from the left. Q is third from the right. How many people sit between them?

Show the answer Hide the answer

None — they sit next to each other.

In a row of seven, third from the right is position 7 − 3 + 1 = 5. P is at 4 and Q at 5, so they are adjacent and nobody sits between them. The conversion "kth from the right is position n − k + 1" is the single most useful formula in this topic.

Q4 In a row of 40 children, Raj is 12th from the left and Sita is 15th from the right. How many children are between them?

Show the answer Hide the answer

13.

Sita is at position 40 − 15 + 1 = 26. Raj is at 12. Between them are 26 − 12 − 1 = 13 children. Subtracting the positions and forgetting the "− 1" is the standard off-by-one here: 26 − 12 = 14 counts Sita herself.

Q5 Eight people sit around a circle facing the centre. How many people sit between two who are directly opposite, counting one way?

Show the answer Hide the answer

3.

Opposite in a circle of eight means four seats apart. Going one way from the first to the second you pass three seats. The general count is n/2 − 1 for an even circle, which is 3 for n = 8.

Q6 A, B, C, D sit in a row of four. D is at the left end. A is not at either end. C sits somewhere to the right of A. B is not at the right end. Who is at the right end?

Show the answer Hide the answer

C.

D takes seat 1. A is not at an end, so A is at 2 or 3. B is not at the right end, and seat 1 is taken, so B is at 2 or 3 as well - which means A and B fill seats 2 and 3 between them, leaving seat 4 for C. That satisfies "C to the right of A" either way round.

Q7 Five people sit in a row. The tallest is in the middle, and heights decrease towards both ends. If the shortest two are at the ends, how many arrangements are possible?

Show the answer Hide the answer

4.

The tallest is fixed in the middle. The two shortest can be arranged at the two ends in 2 ways, and the remaining two in the two inner seats in 2 ways: 2 × 2 = 4. Counting arrangements is often the last step of a seating question, and it is ordinary combinatorics.

Q8 Six friends sit in a row. R is to the immediate left of S. T is at one end. How many arrangements put R and S together?

Show the answer Hide the answer

48.

Tie R and S into one block, in that fixed order, giving 5 items. T must be at one of the two ends: 2 choices. The remaining 4 items arrange in 4! = 24 ways. 2 × 24 = 48. The block is not doubled because the question fixes R to S's left.

Q9 In a circle of 10 people facing the centre, who is 4th to the right of the person who is 3rd to the left of X?

Show the answer Hide the answer

The person immediately to X's right.

Three to the left then four to the right is a net movement of one to the right: −3 + 4 = +1. Compose the moves as signed numbers rather than tracing each step, and reduce modulo 10 if the total exceeds the circle.

Q10 Twelve people sit evenly around a circular table. If person 1 and person 7 are opposite, which number is opposite person 4?

Show the answer Hide the answer

10.

Opposite is six places round in a circle of twelve, which matches 1 and 7. So 4 + 6 = 10. For person 9 it would be 9 + 6 = 15, which wraps to 15 − 12 = 3. Adding half the circle and reducing modulo n answers every "who is opposite" question.

Where people lose marks

  • Converting "kth from the right" wrongly. In a row of n it is position n − k + 1, not n − k.
  • The off-by-one when counting people BETWEEN two positions: subtract the positions and then subtract one more.
  • Getting left and right backwards in a circle. Decide once whether people face the centre and write it on the diagram.
  • Assuming a unique answer. Some of these are deliberately under-specified, and the right answer is what every valid arrangement shares.